Skills
academic-rebuttal
by TobiasLee
Use when an author has received peer-review comments and scores for an academic paper and needs to diagnose underlying reviewer concerns, decide whether a rebuttal is…
Our verdict
We have not reviewed academic-rebuttal yet
No one at Enterprise DNA has checked this listing against its sources. The description comes from public listings gathered automatically. Any fact below shows where it came from and when it was last checked.
From the listing
About academic-rebuttal
A writing tool that helps authors respond to peer-review feedback by diagnosing underlying reviewer concerns, weighing whether a rebuttal is worthwhile, and planning experiments or evidence-grounded responses. It outputs author-review material for the author to finalize, not submission-ready rebuttals, and requires checking venue generative-AI policies before use. The tool avoids fabricating results, reviewer intent, citations, or manuscript locations.
Best for
Academic authors who want structured support in planning and drafting peer-review responses.
Use cases
- Diagnose the core concerns behind peer-review comments and scores
- Plan rebuttal experiments or additional analyses to address reviewer issues
- Draft evidence-grounded response material and revision plans for author review
Notes
academic-rebuttal — writing from TobiasLee.
499 stars on GitHub. Last updated 2026-11-06.
Indexed from github-skill-md. Verified against the live GitHub repo.
Pros
- Helps organize complex feedback into actionable rebuttal strategies
- Emphasizes evidence grounding and avoids fabrication
- Designed to keep the author in control of final content
Cons
- Does not produce submission-ready rebuttals; requires author finalization
- Depends on the author providing accurate manuscript and review context
- Must check venue policies on generative AI before use
Key facts
What we have checked
- Days since the last commit
- 8
- GitHub forks
- 21
- GitHub stars
- 508
- Open issues
- 1
- Releases in the last 90 days
- 0
Each value shows when we last confirmed it and where it came from. Values we have not confirmed are left out, never guessed.
Stars and usage
How academic-rebuttal is growing
495 to 508
Health and security
Is academic-rebuttal looked after, and what do its setup files show
Health score
50 out of 100
| Part | Points | What we saw |
|---|---|---|
| Recent activity | 30 of 30 | Last push 8 days ago |
| Releases | 0 of 15 | 0 releases in 90 days |
| Issue replies | Not counted | The latest check has no issue response reading (fewer than 3 measured issues, or issues switched off) |
| Maintainer | 0 of 15 | Owned by a single user |
| Official source | Not counted | MCP servers only |
Security check static checks
100 out of 100
- Note No dependency list or install command was found in the skill, so there were no packages to look up on OSV.
Sources
Where this comes from
- GitHubRegistry
A source shows what was published when we checked it. It does not certify security, performance or a working installation. Read our method.
Changelog
What changed
No changes recorded yet. Releases, price changes and deprecations appear here, with their dates, once we track them for this record.
Pairs with
Other entries in the index that connect to this one. Click through to see the chain.
ML Paper Writing
Orchestra Research
Draft publication-ready ML papers for NeurIPS, ICML, ICLR, ACL, AAAI and COLM, with verified citations and LaTeX templates.
systems-paper-writing
Orchestra-Research
Comprehensive open-source library of AI research and engineering skills for any AI model. Package the skills and your claude code/codex/gemini agent will be an AI research agent wi
Get the free Developer’s Field Guide
A 27-page field guide to the AI coding workflow with Claude. Claude Code, MCP servers, the prompt patterns that work, and what to delegate. Free.
Enter your work email. We send it straight over, plus a few short notes worth knowing. Unsubscribe any time.